Trendoday

The 'Astra can read and write weights to improve Qwen' post is misleading

0 comments

  • Points1000
  • Comments204
–Rank now
#1Peak rank
2Days on list
348Score · 7d
Nov 3, 2026First seen
Rank · 7 days

On Hacker News

Points
1000
Comments
204
Submitted by
syllogism
Posted
Nov 3, 2026
Site
honnibal.dev

Story details from Hacker News ↗ · linked article on honnibal.dev.

Trending history

The 'Astra can read and write weights to improve Qwen' post is misleading was first seen on Hacker News · Front page on Nov 3, 2026. Since then it has appeared in 92 checks on 2 different days. Its best position was #1 of 30, reached on Nov 3, 16:22 UTC. It dropped off the list after Nov 4, 14:22 UTC.

Rank history

Position on Hacker News · Front page at every check (lower is better).

#1#11#20#30 13:0719:2601:4408:0314:22 Nov 3, 13:07 UTC · #29Nov 3, 13:22 UTC · #21Nov 3, 13:37 UTC · #17Nov 3, 13:52 UTC · #10Nov 3, 14:07 UTC · #9Nov 3, 14:22 UTC · #8Nov 3, 14:37 UTC · #6Nov 3, 14:52 UTC · #6Nov 3, 15:07 UTC · #5Nov 3, 15:22 UTC · #3Nov 3, 15:37 UTC · #3Nov 3, 15:52 UTC · #3Nov 3, 16:07 UTC · #2Nov 3, 16:22 UTC · #1Nov 3, 16:37 UTC · #1Nov 3, 16:52 UTC · #1Nov 3, 17:07 UTC · #1Nov 3, 17:22 UTC · #1Nov 3, 17:37 UTC · #1Nov 3, 17:52 UTC · #1Nov 3, 18:07 UTC · #1Nov 3, 18:22 UTC · #1Nov 3, 18:37 UTC · #1Nov 3, 18:52 UTC · #1Nov 3, 19:07 UTC · #1Nov 3, 19:22 UTC · #1Nov 3, 19:37 UTC · #1Nov 3, 19:52 UTC · #1Nov 3, 20:07 UTC · #1Nov 3, 20:22 UTC · #1Nov 3, 20:37 UTC · #1Nov 3, 20:52 UTC · #1Nov 3, 21:07 UTC · #1Nov 3, 21:22 UTC · #1Nov 3, 21:37 UTC · #1Nov 3, 21:52 UTC · #1Nov 3, 22:07 UTC · #2Nov 3, 22:22 UTC · #2Nov 3, 22:37 UTC · #2Nov 3, 22:52 UTC · #2Nov 3, 23:07 UTC · #2Nov 3, 23:22 UTC · #2Nov 3, 23:37 UTC · #2Nov 3, 23:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 00:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 00:22 UTC · #2Nov 4, 00:37 UTC · #2Nov 4, 00:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 01:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 01:22 UTC · #2Nov 4, 01:37 UTC · #2Nov 4, 01:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 02:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 02:22 UTC · #2Nov 4, 02:37 UTC · #2Nov 4, 02:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 03:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 03:22 UTC · #2Nov 4, 03:37 UTC · #2Nov 4, 03:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 04:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 04:22 UTC · #2Nov 4, 04:37 UTC · #2Nov 4, 04:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 05:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 05:22 UTC · #2Nov 4, 05:37 UTC · #2Nov 4, 05:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 06:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 06:22 UTC · #2Nov 4, 06:37 UTC · #2Nov 4, 06:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 07:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 07:22 UTC · #2Nov 4, 07:37 UTC · #2Nov 4, 07:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 08:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 08:22 UTC · #2Nov 4, 08:37 UTC · #2Nov 4, 08:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 09:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 09:22 UTC · #2Nov 4, 09:37 UTC · #2Nov 4, 09:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 10:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 10:22 UTC · #2Nov 4, 10:37 UTC · #2Nov 4, 10:52 UTC · #2Nov 4, 11:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 12:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 14:07 UTC · #2Nov 4, 14:22 UTC · #2

Last 14 days

Best rank per day (UTC).

Oct 26today

Metric history

Platform metric as reported by Hacker News.

03306611001 13:0719:2601:4408:0314:22 Nov 3, 13:07 UTC · 7Nov 3, 13:22 UTC · 81Nov 3, 13:37 UTC · 134Nov 3, 13:52 UTC · 190Nov 3, 14:07 UTC · 243Nov 3, 14:22 UTC · 287Nov 3, 14:37 UTC · 328Nov 3, 14:52 UTC · 372Nov 3, 15:07 UTC · 427Nov 3, 15:22 UTC · 459Nov 3, 15:37 UTC · 491Nov 3, 15:52 UTC · 522Nov 3, 16:07 UTC · 547Nov 3, 16:22 UTC · 575Nov 3, 16:37 UTC · 600Nov 3, 16:52 UTC · 621Nov 3, 17:07 UTC · 646Nov 3, 17:22 UTC · 675Nov 3, 17:37 UTC · 690Nov 3, 17:52 UTC · 701Nov 3, 18:07 UTC · 715Nov 3, 18:22 UTC · 720Nov 3, 18:37 UTC · 730Nov 3, 18:52 UTC · 744Nov 3, 19:07 UTC · 749Nov 3, 19:22 UTC · 761Nov 3, 19:37 UTC · 766Nov 3, 19:52 UTC · 771Nov 3, 20:07 UTC · 781Nov 3, 20:22 UTC · 784Nov 3, 20:37 UTC · 790Nov 3, 20:52 UTC · 795Nov 3, 21:07 UTC · 803Nov 3, 21:22 UTC · 807Nov 3, 21:37 UTC · 813Nov 3, 21:52 UTC · 822Nov 3, 22:07 UTC · 831Nov 3, 22:22 UTC · 843Nov 3, 22:37 UTC · 848Nov 3, 22:52 UTC · 852Nov 3, 23:07 UTC · 855Nov 3, 23:22 UTC · 860Nov 3, 23:37 UTC · 862Nov 3, 23:52 UTC · 865Nov 4, 00:07 UTC · 872Nov 4, 00:22 UTC · 873Nov 4, 00:37 UTC · 878Nov 4, 00:52 UTC · 883Nov 4, 01:07 UTC · 889Nov 4, 01:22 UTC · 899Nov 4, 01:37 UTC · 905Nov 4, 01:52 UTC · 907Nov 4, 02:07 UTC · 910Nov 4, 02:22 UTC · 910Nov 4, 02:37 UTC · 913Nov 4, 02:52 UTC · 914Nov 4, 03:07 UTC · 916Nov 4, 03:22 UTC · 916Nov 4, 03:37 UTC · 922Nov 4, 03:52 UTC · 924Nov 4, 04:07 UTC · 928Nov 4, 04:22 UTC · 931Nov 4, 04:37 UTC · 932Nov 4, 04:52 UTC · 933Nov 4, 05:07 UTC · 937Nov 4, 05:22 UTC · 941Nov 4, 05:37 UTC · 942Nov 4, 05:52 UTC · 946Nov 4, 06:07 UTC · 949Nov 4, 06:22 UTC · 950Nov 4, 06:37 UTC · 951Nov 4, 06:52 UTC · 954Nov 4, 07:07 UTC · 956Nov 4, 07:22 UTC · 958Nov 4, 07:37 UTC · 961Nov 4, 07:52 UTC · 962Nov 4, 08:07 UTC · 963Nov 4, 08:22 UTC · 963Nov 4, 08:37 UTC · 967Nov 4, 08:52 UTC · 969Nov 4, 09:07 UTC · 969Nov 4, 09:22 UTC · 971Nov 4, 09:37 UTC · 973Nov 4, 09:52 UTC · 976Nov 4, 10:07 UTC · 980Nov 4, 10:22 UTC · 983Nov 4, 10:37 UTC · 986Nov 4, 10:52 UTC · 988Nov 4, 11:07 UTC · 989Nov 4, 12:07 UTC · 995Nov 4, 14:07 UTC · 1000Nov 4, 14:22 UTC · 1001

From the discussion

A few top-level comments from Hacker News, shortened. Read the full thread on Hacker News.

I work in this field (mech interp research) and I agree, the original post is definitely misleading. Some overselling in research is normal but it's a bit much. First, the key result has nothing to do with making Qwen better at math, it just reduces reasoning loops. Reasoning loops are a simple problem: the model…

Speaking for myself. I’ve been aware of a lot of concepts around training, but stayed away from it until very recently. A few weeks ago, I formed a hypothesis that I could get a smaller model good at the specific standards I have for my git commit messages, which are hard to get out of most LLMs today. I spent the…

Wasn’t all that obvious to anyone who read the original post when they got to the section that explicitly explained what the author of this post is now summarizing? Sure if you only read the title and brief at the top you’d walk away without the full picture though. This is a better response imo:…

Questions

Is The 'Astra can read and write weights to improve Qwen' post is misleading trending on Hacker News right now?

Not at the moment. It was last on the list on Nov 4, 14:22 UTC, after 2 days of trending.

What is the highest rank The 'Astra can read and write weights to improve Qwen' post is misleading reached?

#1 on Hacker News · Front page, on Nov 3, 16:22 UTC. Trendoday checks this list every 15 minutes.

How long has The 'Astra can read and write weights to improve Qwen' post is misleading been trending?

It was first seen on Nov 3, 2026 and has been on the list on 2 days (92 checks) since.

How much discussion did it get on Hacker News?

1000 points and 204 comments; submitted by syllogism on Nov 3, 2026.