Trendoday

Unblockable communication with gravity – Science Advances

discuss

  • Points148
  • Comments55
–Rank now
#11Peak rank
2Days on list
86Score · 7d
Nov 19, 2026First seen
Rank · 7 days

On Hacker News

Points
148
Comments
55
Submitted by
rbanffy
Posted
Nov 19, 2026
Site
science.org

Story details from Hacker News ↗ · linked article on science.org.

Trending history

Unblockable communication with gravity – Science Advances was first seen on Hacker News · Front page on Nov 19, 2026. Since then it has appeared in 54 checks on 2 different days. Its best position was #11 of 30, reached on Nov 19, 13:29 UTC. It dropped off the list after Nov 20, 02:29 UTC.

Rank history

Position on Hacker News · Front page at every check (lower is better).

#1#11#20#30 13:1416:3319:5123:1002:29 Nov 19, 13:14 UTC · #15Nov 19, 13:29 UTC · #11Nov 19, 13:44 UTC · #14Nov 19, 13:58 UTC · #14Nov 19, 14:13 UTC · #16Nov 19, 14:28 UTC · #20Nov 19, 14:44 UTC · #20Nov 19, 14:59 UTC · #19Nov 19, 15:14 UTC · #16Nov 19, 15:29 UTC · #16Nov 19, 15:44 UTC · #16Nov 19, 15:59 UTC · #19Nov 19, 16:14 UTC · #18Nov 19, 16:29 UTC · #20Nov 19, 16:44 UTC · #22Nov 19, 16:59 UTC · #21Nov 19, 17:14 UTC · #23Nov 19, 17:29 UTC · #22Nov 19, 17:44 UTC · #23Nov 19, 17:59 UTC · #23Nov 19, 18:14 UTC · #20Nov 19, 18:29 UTC · #19Nov 19, 18:44 UTC · #20Nov 19, 18:59 UTC · #20Nov 19, 19:14 UTC · #22Nov 19, 19:29 UTC · #24Nov 19, 19:44 UTC · #20Nov 19, 19:59 UTC · #21Nov 19, 20:14 UTC · #21Nov 19, 20:29 UTC · #21Nov 19, 20:44 UTC · #21Nov 19, 20:59 UTC · #20Nov 19, 21:14 UTC · #21Nov 19, 21:29 UTC · #22Nov 19, 21:44 UTC · #24Nov 19, 21:59 UTC · #22Nov 19, 22:14 UTC · #21Nov 19, 22:29 UTC · #24Nov 19, 22:44 UTC · #24Nov 19, 22:59 UTC · #24Nov 19, 23:14 UTC · #24Nov 19, 23:29 UTC · #25Nov 19, 23:44 UTC · #25Nov 19, 23:59 UTC · #26Nov 20, 00:14 UTC · #26Nov 20, 00:29 UTC · #28Nov 20, 00:44 UTC · #28Nov 20, 00:59 UTC · #28Nov 20, 01:14 UTC · #28Nov 20, 01:29 UTC · #28Nov 20, 01:44 UTC · #28Nov 20, 01:59 UTC · #28Nov 20, 02:14 UTC · #30Nov 20, 02:29 UTC · #30

Last 14 days

Best rank per day (UTC).

Nov 7today

Metric history

Platform metric as reported by Hacker News.

050100152 13:1416:3319:5123:1002:29 Nov 19, 13:14 UTC · 10Nov 19, 13:29 UTC · 13Nov 19, 13:44 UTC · 14Nov 19, 13:58 UTC · 20Nov 19, 14:13 UTC · 22Nov 19, 14:28 UTC · 25Nov 19, 14:44 UTC · 26Nov 19, 14:59 UTC · 29Nov 19, 15:14 UTC · 32Nov 19, 15:29 UTC · 35Nov 19, 15:44 UTC · 41Nov 19, 15:59 UTC · 43Nov 19, 16:14 UTC · 44Nov 19, 16:29 UTC · 48Nov 19, 16:44 UTC · 49Nov 19, 16:59 UTC · 50Nov 19, 17:14 UTC · 52Nov 19, 17:29 UTC · 53Nov 19, 17:44 UTC · 55Nov 19, 17:59 UTC · 59Nov 19, 18:14 UTC · 66Nov 19, 18:29 UTC · 71Nov 19, 18:44 UTC · 73Nov 19, 18:59 UTC · 75Nov 19, 19:14 UTC · 78Nov 19, 19:29 UTC · 82Nov 19, 19:44 UTC · 84Nov 19, 19:59 UTC · 86Nov 19, 20:14 UTC · 92Nov 19, 20:29 UTC · 97Nov 19, 20:44 UTC · 100Nov 19, 20:59 UTC · 106Nov 19, 21:14 UTC · 110Nov 19, 21:29 UTC · 111Nov 19, 21:44 UTC · 115Nov 19, 21:59 UTC · 120Nov 19, 22:14 UTC · 122Nov 19, 22:29 UTC · 125Nov 19, 22:44 UTC · 129Nov 19, 22:59 UTC · 131Nov 19, 23:14 UTC · 133Nov 19, 23:29 UTC · 134Nov 19, 23:44 UTC · 135Nov 19, 23:59 UTC · 136Nov 20, 00:14 UTC · 138Nov 20, 00:29 UTC · 143Nov 20, 00:44 UTC · 145Nov 20, 00:59 UTC · 147Nov 20, 01:14 UTC · 147Nov 20, 01:29 UTC · 148Nov 20, 01:44 UTC · 150Nov 20, 01:59 UTC · 151Nov 20, 02:14 UTC · 152Nov 20, 02:29 UTC · 152

From the discussion

A few top-level comments from Hacker News, shortened. Read the full thread on Hacker News.

It seems like they missed the opportunity to put the big heavy thing on a rotating disk and then encode the data as changes in velocity (frequency domain) which is way easier to do than an elevator, especially with a PM motor. This is basically FM vs AM. Intuitively if the thing is heavy enough it should have decent…

Would it be easy to jam the signal ? Say, you have a big, heavy double pendulum moving close to the emitter. The moving mass would disturb the signal, and predicting the evolution of a double pendulum is not easy due to its instability (it's not periodic for example, so no Fourier analysis)

The key idea seems to be: Since mass cannot be negative, there is no gravitational analog of charge cancelation and hence no way to hide or screen the presence of mass. Perhaps they address this in the paper, but it occurs to me that the obvious countermeasure is to shield with a large positive mass, and then to…

Questions

Is Unblockable communication with gravity – Science Advances trending on Hacker News right now?

Not at the moment. It was last on the list on Nov 20, 02:29 UTC, after 2 days of trending.

What is the highest rank Unblockable communication with gravity – Science Advances reached?

#11 on Hacker News · Front page, on Nov 19, 13:29 UTC. Trendoday checks this list every 15 minutes.

How long has Unblockable communication with gravity – Science Advances been trending?

It was first seen on Nov 19, 2026 and has been on the list on 2 days (54 checks) since.

How much discussion did it get on Hacker News?

148 points and 55 comments; submitted by rbanffy on Nov 19, 2026.